Online Ordering for pickup is Coming Soon! Benton Park's Favorite Neighbor. Taste the magic of our house-made ice cream! No matter which sugar cone you prefer, we have a flavor to match it. At A Spoonful of Sugar, we believe that the best ice cream starts with the best ingredients.
That's why we source our milk and cream from local farms, and use only the freshest fruits, nuts, and other ingredients. Our commitment to quality means you can taste the difference in every scoop.
Our ice cream is handcrafted in small batches, using traditional techniques and modern twists. We start by pasteurizing the milk and cream, then add our signature mix-ins and flavors. Each batch is churned slowly to create a smooth, creamy texture that melts in your mouth. Everyone loves a scoop of classic vanilla ice cream. Smooth texture and sweet to taste, but without anything too extra. Leave the complex treats to the adventurers'. A smooth blend of vanilla and pure cocoa, scooped just the way you like it on a sugar cone.
House-made classic vanilla ice cream with fresh made brownie batter and brownie pieces folded into it?! Yes, Please! We've never met a more fun guy! Fresh strawberries meet our smooth signature classic vanilla ice cream blend. So tasty, it might make you change your favorite flavor! America's Favorite Cookie joins the lineup.
We start with our signature vanilla recipe and then we add a generous amount of cookies until we feel there is just enough Come be the judge and try it today! You kept asking for it! So we made it happen! Benton Park's Favorite Flavor has a load of vanilla wafers, fresh bananas and more fresh, sweet ingredients.
